Fort Collins Real Estate Search

Fort Collins Historical Properties for Sale

Our website features the best real estate search for historical properties available in Fort Collins and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official REALTOR®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Curious about what’s happening in the Fort Collins real estate market? Sign up for a  Fort Collins Real Estate Market Report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold!

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Newest Fort Collins Historical Homes for Sale

$431,000
2 Beds 2 Baths 1003115 MLS ACTIVE/BACKUP Status
Welcome to 129 2nd Street Fort Collins CO! The Buckingham neighborhood is the closest neighborhood to the Poudre River in Fort Collins. This home has a new roof, new water heater, newer furnace, upgraded attic insulation, stucco exterior, new windows, additional storm windows, a storm door and more. It is ready to take great care of you and your family. Easy to maintain inside and outside with a xeriscaped yard. The back yard has alley access. The front entry has a concrete patio with a flagstone addition and sunken fire pit. The concrete patio has an attached pathway to the garage and out to the sidewalk leading you to all the gems of Old Town including: Buckingham Park, Sugar Beet Park, Udall Natural Area, Gustav Swanson Natural Area, Homestead Natural Area, Springer Natural Area, Poudre River Whitewater Park, Fort Collins Museum of Discovery, Old Town Library, Smokestack Pottery, Odell Brewery, New Belgium Brewery, Sweetwater Brewery, Snowbank Brewing, Ginger and Baker, Silver Grill Cafe, Back Porch Cafe, Bas Bleu Theatre Company, Northside Aztlan Community Center and the list goes on. This one level home has an entry step and no more. The 2 bedrooms, 1 1/2 bath, laundry room, kitchen and living room are all on the same level. Original hardwood floors, wood doors and wood window trim are still here. Some of the wood windows have working window weights still in place. Schedule your visit to the best neighborhood in Fort Collins and make 129 2nd Street your next home!

129 2nd St, Fort Collins

$1,195,000
4 Beds 3 Baths 1002736 MLS ACTIVE Status
Fantastic 1920's Craftsman home, set on quiet West Oak Street. Upon entry you'll notice the stately front porch, welcoming & grand, with the original Craftsman Pillars. Inside the home you will notice the stylistic architectural details such as the layout of the Craftsman style floor plan to the custom millwork that mimics the pillars on the front porch. The main floor features a front living & dining room, configured in an open concept, 2 bedrooms, a remodeled kitchen & bathroom. (The remodel of these 2 spaces was completed in 2023.) The kitchen features new appliances, countertops, backsplash & single basin composite sink. The heat source throughout is in-floor radiant heat, and the boiler + combo hot water heater was installed in 2022. This home offers 2 options for primary bedrooms. One is located on the 2nd floor & was added to the home in 2000, (the roof, sewer & water line were also replaced, then.) That space is a private retreat featuring an en-suite w/ clawfoot tub & skylights, which provide abundant natural light. The 2nd story also contains a large living / study area complete with closet space, additional storage, and several skylights. The space feels so homey and cozy! One element of surprise is the attached additional dwelling unit. This space could also serve as a Primary Suite. Step down from the kitchen into a cozy secondary dining space and continue into the ADU. This space is an impressive 530 square feet, and is fully accessible for all abilities and is so charming & comfortable. The space includes stained concrete flooring w/ radiant heat below, a 3/4 bath, a generously sized bedroom and a living room area. In 2014 the current owners completed the kitchen remodel of this space and enclosed it to make it more separate from the house. The option exists to integrate this back into the main house. Located in the heart of the West Side Neighborhood, just steps to City Park, Little on Mountain Restaurant, Mountain Avenue and the Poudre River.

914 W Oak St, Fort Collins

$788,039
3 Beds 3 Baths 1002165 MLS ACTIVE/BACKUP Status
Location Location Location! Literally less than one block from City Park where you can enjoy festivals, 4th of July fireworks, picnics, exercise trail, walking, fishing, swimming pool, reserve a pavilion for private parties, many different sports activities, Tuesday Food Truck Rally, music and much more. Can also walk or ride your bikes to Old Town for dining, shopping, breweries, distilleries... This 1505 SF 2 bedroom, 2 bath home with main level hardwood flooring is in excellent condition PLUS there is the detached 509 SF studio that is currently the 3rd bedroom with 3/4 bath. The amazing 0.28-acre lot is meticulously manicured and great parcel to build an ADU. There have been large family reunions, a wedding, large 4th of July BBQs and other fun private events on this property. Just use your imagination for the studio's many possible uses...can be an office, guest bedroom, in-law suite, art studio, home gym, she shed, workshop etc. The lower level of the home had a bedroom but that area has been opened up into a large family room with an egress window. Can easily add another bedroom back into floorplan. Newer furnace, A/C, tankless on-demand water heater and kitchen appliances. 2 newer large sheds. Sprinkler system. Has been used as an Executive Extended Stay Home for customers in between sales and purchases and Personal Family Enjoyment...so much fun to be had on this property! Seller is a Licensed Agent.

525 City Park Ave, Fort Collins

$1,995,000
4 Beds 2557186 MLS ACTIVE Status
Exclusive Opportunity to build full custom with Locally Rooted Old Town Design Build on an amazing lot in Old Town Fort Collins, desirable west side Grant Ave. location! 5,042 sqft. Sprawling Open Ranch, 4 Bedrooms + main flr study or additional 5th Bdrm/5 Baths, Lrg Lower Level Rec. room, 10 ft volume ceilings on the main level, 9ft foundation walls finished lower level - nestled on over 11,000 sqft lot double lot! Epicurean's Kitchen features a 9ft island, stunning Dacor Gourmet Kitchen appliance package, 48" commercial style free standing duel fuel GAS range, Quartz Countertops throughout, Modern & Timeless Natural elements, Organic Modern w/ state of art the features, functionality & generous allowances. Oversized Marvin windows, Milarc cabinetry, Wide Plank European Oak flrs & cozy wool carpet in the lower level and warm natural daylight throughout. Longtime Expert & Local Artisan Craftsmanship! Single Floor living, nearly 2,600 finished sqft. on the main + nearly 1,200 finished in the lower level + fully insulated, finished, 28 ft deep & Oversized 2 car garage. Super flexible living + stunning cozy linear fireplace on both levels. Low maintenance exterior, combination of hard coat stucco system, board and batten, tongue + groove ceiling treatment. Just down the street from the direct access to the Poudre River Trail & Lee Martinez Park & the Discovery Museum. Ultra-Comfort blown R-60 in ceilings + R-30 in walls 200 AMP service & Solar Ready/Dual Zoned HVAC, Tankless H2O with instant hot recirc. line. Enjoy the perfect quality of life in Old Town Fort Collins close to everything, endless Colorado recreation abounds w/ hiking, fishing, biking, kayaking, trail running, and within an easy bike ride to 3 parks (City Park, Lee Martinez, and Library Park), restaurants, shopping, breweries & live music. See listing agent for all features, details, timing and structure. Old Town Fort Collins no Metro + no HOA! Contact agent to schedule appointment with builder.

516 N Grant Ave, Fort Collins

$780,000
4 Beds 2 Baths 4054378 MLS ACTIVE Status
You're going to love the charm of this Fort Collins, CO gem! Built in 1915, this captivating 2-story home boasts an enviable location and an expansive lot. Enjoy leisurely strolls or bike rides to Old Town, the Colorado State University campus, parks, restaurants, bars, breweries, and the tranquil Spring Creek Trail. Because of its generous lot size, this property invites the possibility of expansion to create your dream living space. Whether you're looking for a spacious single-family home or a lucrative rental opportunity, you can make it happen on this property! Inside discover a thoughtfully laid out floor plan, including a recently remodeled kitchen and spacious dining and living rooms. The home features 2 bedrooms and a bath on the main level and 2 non-conforming bedrooms and a bath tucked under a hip roof upstairs. The second level offers the potential for rental income as it has a separate entrance and is plumbed for a kitchenette. The back yard is an oasis surrounded by a new privacy fence and maintained with irrigation. Mature fruit trees and a pergola offer shade and sun options that invite outdoor living most months of the year. At the back of the lot, a 2-car detached garage features a loft area with additional climate-controlled square footage, providing room for storage, a studio, or an office. Convenient alley access ensures ease of use and ample off-street parking. Nestled in a quiet, desirable neighborhood, this home embodies the essence of a peaceful retreat while being at the heart of all the vibrant amenities Fort Collins has to offer. Don't miss the chance to live in the heart of Fort Collins on a spacious lot. This property combines location, lot size, and versatility, making it a remarkable find. Schedule your viewing today and explore the possibilities that await!

642 Smith St, Fort Collins

$780,000
4 Beds 2 Baths 994384 MLS ACTIVE Status
You're going to love the charm of this Fort Collins, CO gem! Built in 1915, this captivating 2-story home boasts an enviable location and an expansive lot. Enjoy leisurely strolls or bike rides to Old Town, the Colorado State University campus, parks, restaurants, bars, breweries, and the tranquil Spring Creek Trail. Because of its generous lot size, this property invites the possibility of expansion to create your dream living space. Whether you're looking for a spacious single-family home or a lucrative rental opportunity, you can make it happen on this property! Inside discover a thoughtfully laid out floor plan, including a recently remodeled kitchen and spacious dining and living rooms. The home features 2 bedrooms and a bath on the main level and 2 non-conforming bedrooms and a bath tucked under a hip roof upstairs. The second level offers the potential for rental income as it has a separate entrance and is plumbed for a kitchenette. The back yard is an oasis surrounded by a new privacy fence and maintained with irrigation. Mature fruit trees and a pergola offer shade and sun options that invite outdoor living most months of the year. At the back of the lot, a 2-car detached garage features a loft area with additional climate-controlled square footage, providing room for storage, a studio, or an office. Convenient alley access ensures ease of use and ample off-street parking. Nestled in a quiet, desirable neighborhood, this home embodies the essence of a peaceful retreat while being at the heart of all the vibrant amenities Fort Collins has to offer. Don't miss the chance to live in the heart of Fort Collins on a spacious lot. This property combines location, lot size, and versatility, making it a remarkable find. Schedule your viewing today and explore the possibilities that await!

642 Smith St, Fort Collins

Start Your Search
The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from Information and Real Estate Services, LLC under IRES Rules © Copyright IRES, and is provided for limited non-commercial use. Information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Real estate listings held by other brokerage firms are included in this site and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing brokers. Listing broker has attempted to offer accurate data, but buyers are advised to confirm all items.
Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed by the MLS
Listing data last updated: