Greeley Real Estate Search

Greeley Properties between $400,000 and $500,000 for Sale

Our website features the best real estate search for available properties between $400,000 and $500,000 in Greeley and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official REALTOR®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Curious about what’s happening in the Greeley real estate market? Sign up for a  Greeley Real Estate Market Report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold!

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Newest Greeley Properties between $400,000 and $500,000 for Sale

3100 W 6th St, Greeley
$417,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1070403 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE Status
Fully Remodeled West Greeley Ranch, Corner Lot, No HOA or Metro tax, with a 2-1 RATE BUYDOWN Available! Completely remodeled top to bottom, so you get to move in and start living... not start a project list. And it gets better. Use our preferred lender and you'll get a 2-1 rate buy down to help make those first two years of homeownership a little easier. The main level has new luxury vinyl plank flooring, the whole house has been freshly painted, and there's new lighting and new ceiling fans throughout the main level. The kitchen has all new stainless steel appliances, new backsplash, new hardware, and a large farmhouse sink (the kind you'll actually use every day). Both bathrooms were completely renovated with new tile surrounds and new fixtures. Even the little things are new: hinges, door knobs, cabinet pulls, all of it NEW. Downstairs, new carpet makes the basement an easy spot for movie nights, a home office, or guest space. Outside, new exterior paint, cedar shutters, and new front landscaping give it real curb appeal. The large corner lot has a fully fenced backyard with room to garden, grill, play, or let the dog run. And the big-ticket items nobody wants to replace right after closing? Newer HVAC with central air, water heater and double-pane windows. Location-wise, you're close to Franklin Park, Broadview Park, and Franklin Middle School, and just minutes from shopping, dining, and US-34. No HOA or Metro tax, either.If you've been waiting for an updated, actually move-in ready home in west Greeley, this is the one to see. Schedule your showing today! Buydown subject to buyer qualification and lender terms.

3100 W 6th St, Greeley

2652 51st Ave, Greeley
$449,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 9525921 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE Status
Welcome to 2652 51st Avenue - a beautifully maintained 3-bedroom, 3-bathroom ranch-style home, a park-like backyard, a fully finished basement and a home that has already had all the expensive work done for you. All in West Greeley's highly popular Highland Park neighborhood, offering no HOA and no metro district. Pull up to 2652 51st Avenue and feel the difference. Set on an expansive 0.35-acre lot - over 15,000 square feet of outdoor space - this home delivers the kind of room to breathe that is increasingly hard to find. With a Class 4 roof replaced in 2019, windows updated in 2015, and an active radon mitigation system already in place, the heavy lifting has been done. This is a home you can simply move into and enjoy. The main floor is thoughtfully designed for ease and flow, with wood and tile flooring throughout the living, dining, and kitchen areas. The kitchen has been beautifully remodeled, featuring a custom decorative range hood and premium appliances that make cooking a genuine pleasure. A cozy see-through gas fireplace sits between the living and family rooms, offering two ways to enjoy its warmth on chilly Colorado evenings. The primary suite includes its own electric fireplace, adding ambiance and comfort at the end of a long day. Three bedrooms, including a spacious primary suite, and three bathrooms mean everyone has their own space and no one waits in line on busy mornings. Main floor laundry make everyday living effortless. The finished basement expands the home significantly, providing the ultimate flex space for a home office, gym, media room, or game room - whatever your lifestyle demands. Step outside and the backyard steals the show. The covered back patio features a tongue-and-groove ceiling and sleek epoxy flooring - perfect for outdoor dining and summer relaxation. Privacy fencing, mature landscaping, a retaining wall, and a French drain create a massive canvas for gardening, entertaining, and yes, pet zoomies.

2652 51st Ave, Greeley

1543 40th Ave Ct, Greeley
$485,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1069832 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE Status
NEW UPDATES!! Enjoy peace and privacy in this beautifully updated home located on a low-traffic cul-de-sac just minutes from Bittersweet Park and UNC! A beautifully landscaped front yard greets you with lush greenery and thoughtful touches that make coming home feel special every single time. Inside, you're welcomed by a spacious open-concept living and dining area featuring vaulted ceilings, FRESH interior paint, large windows, and plenty of space to host or relax with ease. The kitchen is equipped with ample prep space and storage, stainless steel appliances, granite countertops, and a stylish tiled backsplash. A breakfast bar adds convenience and makes morning routines feel effortless. Adjacent to the kitchen, the family room features a cozy gas fireplace, providing a warm and comfortable space for relaxation and family gatherings. Upstairs, an overlook provides a bird's eye view of the living spaces, all enhanced by newly installed carpets that extend across the entire upper level. There are three bedrooms on this level, including a primary suite with an ensuite bathroom. The basement is designed for entertainment, wired for surround sound and featuring a wet bar, making it an ideal space for hosting movie nights or parties. An additional bedroom and a newly added bathroom in the basement make it perfect for guests, while bonus unfinished spaces offer potential for storage or further customization according to your needs. Outside, the spacious fenced backyard boasts an extended concrete and brick patio with a pergola, surrounded by mature trees that bring extra privacy and a cool breeze. This outdoor paradise offers plenty of space for outdoor dining or simply enjoying the serene environment. Enjoy the ease of living just minutes from shopping, dining, and everything else Greeley has to offer-this home puts it all within reach. Additional updates include new furnace and A/C. Gas fireplace is also newly cleaned and inspected.

1543 40th Ave Ct, Greeley

811 47th Ave Ct, Greeley
$495,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1069626 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE Status
This beautiful ranch home is on 0.38 acres and has room for RVs, boats, a workshop and anything else you could possibly want! A rare find to have such a versatile property in town with no HOA. This sprawling ranch has 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms on the main level, plus another bedroom and a 3/4 bathroom in the basement. The enormous family room addition has a gas fireplace and provides tons of space for relaxing, entertaining, and recreation. A sunroom adds another quaint space to an already charming home with its tile floor, walls of windows, and a wood burning stove. The primary bedroom has a sitting area with a closet, plus a lowered space for the bed with another closet, and an attached 3/4 bathroom. Off the primary bedroom is a separate yard area with a greenhouse and garden beds. There is also a hot tub connection in this private outdoor retreat. Outside, you can park an RV (or 2!) on the front driveway and north side yard. The detached 2-car garage is oversized and also has a long driveway for additional off street parking. Outdoor spaces are stunning with patios, a firepit, a fountain, and a large grassy area. There's a gate under the arbor where additional items could be brought into the yard for storage, making the fire pit area capable of multiple uses. Allen Park is 1 house away and has a playground and a lake that gets stocked. This is a remarkable property with tons of features most others cannot provide - again with no HOA, and under $500k! Come see it and dream about the ways this home and lot can fit your future lifestyle!

811 47th Ave Ct, Greeley

1711 15th Ave, Greeley
$437,500
5 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1069439 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE UNDER CONTRACT Status
Classic Fairacres Charm with Solar Efficiency! Charming bungalow in this desirable neighborhood (no HOA), just a short block away from beautiful Glenmere lake & park, conveniently located near the hospital, schools, shopping, restaurants, library and downtown. This character-filled home features arched doorways, sturdy cinderblock-and-plaster walls, coved ceilings, original wood floors, cozy nooks with a ton of built-ins, so many windows allowing abundant light. Enjoy a large main-floor laundry room with double windows and folding table, brick-faced wood burning fireplace in the living room and flex-space for an office, nursery, library, sunroom...so many options on the main floor! Brand New full house A/C, Class 4 hail-resistant roof, 2 hot water heaters, 100% solar hot water with a 500 gallon tank, 2 furnaces with one that defers to the solar hot water first, and solar electric panels which keep monthly electric bills very low and affordable. Step outside to a private lush, green lawn enclosed by a wooden fence featuring a huge 30' x 18' deck with a pergola that allows sun and shade...perfect for entertaining and outdoor living most of the year. This is a RARE opportunity to own a home with timeless character, thoughtful updates, plenty of windows and light, and exceptional solar efficiency in a convenient location that you simply don't find in newer construction. This home qualifies for the GHope buyer assistance program.

1711 15th Ave, Greeley

1520 12th Ave, Greeley
$435,000
6 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1069429 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE Status
Welcome to 1520 12th Ave in downtown Greeley. This charming 1906 Arts and Crafts home in Greeley's Cranford neighborhood, just blocks from the University of Northern Colorado, features turn-of-the-century Arts and Crafts details. Original woodwork still sets the tone: trim, moldings, and built-ins that give the house the warmth this era is known for. With the architectural symmetry of a four-square elevation, this home is the perfect choice for anyone looking to own a piece of history close to Greeley's hub of activity. Previously used as a duplex, this home has two separate entrances, a shared laundry room, and ample parking in the backyard lot. The basement is ready to be finished and could possibly serve as a rental that generates income for someone living upstairs. This home is perfectly suited for a house hack and is ready for the next owner to turn it into a great investment property. The home has 4 bedrooms upstairs and 2.5 baths. It features an oversized kitchen and dining room, plus a beautiful living room with a fireplace. The basement is set up to accommodate 2 additional bedrooms and another bedroom, with a kitchen and living room space. The location does a lot of the work. Cranford sits close to campus, downtown Greeley, and everyday services, with a walkable older-neighborhood streetscape of early-20th-century homes. Public water and sewer serve the property. A house with intact Arts and Crafts detail, room to grow downstairs, and a Cranford address near UNC.Come see the potential in this amazing house!

1520 12th Ave, Greeley

1731 70th Ave, Greeley
$484,000
5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1069408 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE Status
OFFERING $10,000 AT CLOSING!!! This 2002 ranch-style home offers 5 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, and plenty of room for comfortable living and entertaining. Home has been pre-inspected! BRAND NEW AC unit as well as a BRAND NEW heat pump and high efficiency furnace, helping to lower your gas bill! Ideally situated in Greeley, this home combines functional living spaces with desirable indoor and outdoor amenities. The main level features an open and welcoming layout with vaulted ceilings, abundant natural light, and a spacious kitchen with a BRAND NEW quartz countertop and backsplash, and a pantry that flows seamlessly into the dining area. The primary suite provides a peaceful retreat complete with a beautiful 5-piece bathroom featuring custom tile.The fully finished basement adds incredible versatility, offering two additional bedrooms and a 3/4 bathroom, perfect for guests, a growing household, a home office, or additional living space. Outside, enjoy your own LARGE private backyard featuring a patio, kids play set, and chicken coop, creating the perfect space to relax, collect fresh eggs, entertain, and enjoy Colorado evenings. The attached 2 car garage provides convenient parking and additional storage. With its spacious floor plan, finished basement, private backyard, and desirable ranch-style layout, 1731 70th Ave offers the space and flexibility you've been looking for. Come see all this Greeley home has to offer!

1731 70th Ave, Greeley

1315 11th Ave, Greeley
$445,000
7 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 2197205 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE Status
Wonderful residential income property. Two parcels included in this sale, price includes both parcels. Primary parcel has a Craftsman style home built in 1924, converted to a 4 unit property, each with private exterior entrances. All units share forced air for heat, and 2 water heaters. Separate shared laundry room. Roof replaced in 9/2022. Five parking spaces behind the house. Unit 1 - Large main floor 2 bedroom. Features preserved charm and character with original built-in shelves and cabinets with glass doors in the dining room. Claw foot tub in the bathroom with a shower ring. Refrigerator is new. Unit 2 - Basement unit with 2 bedrooms. Baseboard heat in bedrooms. Must walk through second bedroom to get to bathroom. Gas stove. Unit 3 - Main floor studio on with a spacious bedroom/living with commercial-grade carpet, 1 bathroom that has a newer toilet, sink and surround shower, and a kitchen with plenty of natural light featuring a gas stove. Unit 4 - Basement unit with 2 bedrooms with baseboard heating, a cute and reasonably sized kitchen with a gas stove, and claw foot tub in the bathroom with a shower sprayer. Secondary included parcel address is 1116 13th street - alley access only to this lot. Lot dimensions are approximately 50'x50'. There is a one car garage with a garage door and an old carriage house. CURRENT ZONING ALLOWS FOR POTENTIAL MULTIFAMILY BUIDING - buyer to verify and investigate. All information deemed reliable, but not guaranteed. Buyer to verify all information, including use and possible use, zoning, square footage, and conduct inspections and due diligence. Also 1 multi unit propertie available in separate listings: 1115 12th street

1315 11th Ave, Greeley

1510 7th Ave, Greeley
$459,000
5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1069223 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE Status
Zoned C-H. 2 Full Kitchens! WorkShop & Parking! ReModeled Huge Home. Custom Entranceway w/Flex Office/Sitting Room. Main Level 9ft ceilings, Original HardWood Flooring, Crown Molding & Open Floor Plan. Free Standing Wood Burning Stove & Custom Shelving. Updated Main Level Expansive Kitchen has Granite "Galaxy" Countertops, Shaker Cabinets w/Pantry, Gas Top Double Jenn-Air Oven, Coffee Bar, Peninsula & Wood Pipe Shelving. Primary Bedroom w/Walk-in plus Separate Closet, Barn Door to Full Private Bath, Soaker Tub, Shelving & Vessel Sink w/Waterfall Faucet. 2nd Bedroom on Main. Off Kitchen, a Full Size W/D in Redesigned Hall w/Incredible Light to Sunroom, Full Bath, Back Walk out Door & Entrance to Second Living Space. Main Bath Features all New Shower Surround w/Waterfall. Sunroom, w/Frosted Door, Double Pane Windows & New Pella Slider to Great Back Patio. Hall Split Stairs Entrance to Daylight Basement w/Separate, Duplex or Multi Generational Living. All New Lifeproof LVP Flooring, 2nd Country Kitchen w/Cabinet Pantries & Gas Range. Second Living Room/Rec Room & ReModeled Full Bath w/Soaker Tub, Waterfall Faucet & Pocket Door. Second W/D stackable Hookups in Dedicated Hall. 3 Bedrooms have redesigned Closets & Egress Windows. Bonus Storage Room at Stairs & in Utility Area off of Laundry Hall. Entire Lot has New Landscaping, Sod, Updated Irrigation, Mulch, Plant Beds, Walkways, Fencing & Double Gates. A standout feature is the 864-sq.-ft. detached Garage & Workshop with Cabinetry & Counters, 220V, Electrical panel & Overhead Storage & Attic Space. Private Alley Access. C-H Zoning allows Multiple Uses. Crushed-Asphalt driveway w/Gated RV/Boat, Truck parking. Major updates include NEW siding, Main level Windows, HVAC system, Flooring, Lighting and Paint. Enjoy Expansive Exterior "Zones" & spacious backyard patios. Conveniently located just blocks from UNC & Newly Modernized downtown Greeley. Local Restaurants, Fare, Shops, Entertainment & Markets within walking distance.

1510 7th Ave, Greeley

1333 87th Ave, Greeley
$465,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1068977 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE Status
$15,000. PRICE IMPROVEMENT! $7500. ADDITIONAL BUYER INCENTIVES when combined with Preferred Lender options!! PRICED TO SELL!! This BEAUTIFUL open floorplan has the sought after, popular split-level layout, FULLY UPGRADED, and already expanded into a true 4-bedroom home, 3 Baths and 3 CAR GARAGE with a FINISHED basement. BETTER than New... It lives bigger, feels warmer, and is ready for everyday life and weekend entertaining. Fresh paint throughout. Thoughtfully designed living spaces, this turnkey home delivers the comfort, upgrades & peace of mind you are looking for. Step inside to the open main level, where the living room and kitchen flow together. SS appliances, including the refrigerator, stove and dishwasher all less than a year old! It is an easy gathering space for weeknight dinners, homework at the island and weekend relaxation. A few steps away, the lower-level great room gives you a second living area that works equally well as a family hangout, media space, or overflow for holidays. The primary suite is a standout. The 5-piece master bath and generous walk-in closet turn the end of the day into a retreat. Three additional bedrooms along with the finished basement adds flexibility. Outside, the backyard is already set up to use: a well manicured landscape, a professionally installed, large concrete pad ready for grilling outside, friends, family, and Colorado evenings. For peace of mind, Owners had HVAC/Furnace serviced & cleaned recently. Quality home construction, upgrades already completed, a finished basement, and a practical outdoor space in West Greeley. Come see how well it lives. Shows like new. NO METRO ,Truly MOVE-IN READY. ** Buyer and Buyer broker to verify all information, measurements, taxes, schools, and zoning.

1333 87th Ave, Greeley

8607 Waterside Way Unit Lot 60, Greeley
$408,000
1068607 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE Status
The Lake Reserve at The Cache offers a rare opportunity to build a custom home in a gated setting unlike anything else in West Greeley. Lot 60 is an approximately .31-acre estate homesite within this first release, pairing planned gated access with private lakes, open space and the natural landscape of the Poudre River corridor. Private trails wind through The Lake Reserve between the lakes and Poudre River, while the Poudre River Trail runs through the larger Cache community, providing convenient access to the regional trail system. Planned recreational access to the lakes includes kayaking, paddleboarding, swimming and fishing, along with a future private lakeside amenity for residents. Thoughtful architectural standards create a cohesive sense of place while allowing each home to be distinctly its own. Buyers may work with one of The Cache's Preferred Builder Guild members or bring a custom builder for consideration and approval. Located within the Windsor School District, The Cache feels removed while remaining remarkably convenient, approximately five minutes from West Greeley amenities and ten minutes from downtown Windsor. The lakes are currently drawn down for rare maintenance. Beyond The Lake Reserve, The Post will thoughtfully reimagine historic farmstead buildings as a place for gathering and community, adding another dimension to life at The Cache. Price includes a non-potable water tap.

8607 Waterside Way Unit Lot 60, Greeley

8613 Waterside Way Unit Lot 59, Greeley
$410,000
1068606 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE Status
The Lake Reserve at The Cache offers a rare opportunity to build a custom home in a gated setting unlike anything else in West Greeley. Lot 59 is an approximately .31-acre estate homesite within this first release, pairing planned gated access with private lakes, open space and the natural landscape of the Poudre River corridor. Private trails wind through The Lake Reserve between the lakes and Poudre River, while the Poudre River Trail runs through the larger Cache community, providing convenient access to the regional trail system. Planned recreational access to the lakes includes kayaking, paddleboarding, swimming and fishing, along with a future private lakeside amenity for residents. Thoughtful architectural standards create a cohesive sense of place while allowing each home to be distinctly its own. Buyers may work with one of The Cache's Preferred Builder Guild members or bring a custom builder for consideration and approval. Located within the Windsor School District, The Cache feels removed while remaining remarkably convenient, approximately five minutes from West Greeley amenities and ten minutes from downtown Windsor. The lakes are currently drawn down for rare maintenance. Beyond The Lake Reserve, The Post will thoughtfully reimagine historic farmstead buildings as a place for gathering and community, adding another dimension to life at The Cache. Price includes a non-potable water tap.

8613 Waterside Way Unit Lot 59, Greeley

8619 Waterside Way Unit Lot 58, Greeley
$400,000
1068605 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE Status
The Lake Reserve at The Cache offers a rare opportunity to build a custom home in a gated setting unlike anything else in West Greeley. Lot 58 is an approximately .31-acre estate homesite within this first release, pairing planned gated access with private lakes, open space and the natural landscape of the Poudre River corridor. Private trails wind through The Lake Reserve between the lakes and Poudre River, while the Poudre River Trail runs through the larger Cache community, providing convenient access to the regional trail system. Planned recreational access to the lakes includes kayaking, paddleboarding, swimming and fishing, along with a future private lakeside amenity for residents. Thoughtful architectural standards create a cohesive sense of place while allowing each home to be distinctly its own. Buyers may work with one of The Cache's Preferred Builder Guild members or bring a custom builder for consideration and approval. Located within the Windsor School District, The Cache feels removed while remaining remarkably convenient, approximately five minutes from West Greeley amenities and ten minutes from downtown Windsor. The lakes are currently drawn down for rare maintenance. Beyond The Lake Reserve, The Post will thoughtfully reimagine historic farmstead buildings as a place for gathering and community, adding another dimension to life at The Cache. Price includes a non-potable water tap.

8619 Waterside Way Unit Lot 58, Greeley

2125 44th Ave, Greeley
$463,000
5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 8955356 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE Status
$12,000 Price Cut! Welcome to 2125 44th Ave in the heart of Greeley. This amazing 5 Bedroom 4 bathroom homes has everything and more. Step inside and feel greeted by the formal living room with large bay windows, and space for cozy conversations and views of the front of the home. Watch as the world goes by in comfort and style. Continue into the home and you will be greeted to a large and open floor planned family room, kitchen, and dining room area. The kitchen offers huge amounts of counter top space, storage with heavy oak wood cabinets, and views into the family room. The dining area next to the kitchen offers great space for family dinners and views out towards the backyard. Into the family room and you will find an amazing area for family gatherings, football parties, or whatever ones desires would be. With a fireplace and more large windows to the backyard, the natural light and open space is the perfect spot. Heading upstairs, you will be greeted by the Primary Suite and three large bedrooms. The Primary suite is situated towards the rear of the home, offering privacy and natural light all in one. The on-suite bathroom offers a lovely shower, vanity, and sink combo perfect for a at home getaway. The Secondary Bedrooms offer great space and storage for any family members who are making them their home, as well as a full bathroom that offers great space for a large families needs. Heading into the basement, this home offers bonus after bonus. This basement offers a large bonus room perfect for another bedroom, a sports/media room, game room and so much more. The additional fifth bedroom and bathroom offer another great space for visiting guest, or family member looking for a little more privacy while still at home. Lets not forget the stunning backyard, with two large sheds, a deck, and ample space for year round outdoor activity. This home is one that should not be missed!!!

2125 44th Ave, Greeley

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of Information and Real Estate Services, LLC as distributed by MLS GRID.


Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker of MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. Some listings have been excluded from this website.


How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!